Files
LEDMatrix/test/test_pixlet_renderer_contract.py
ChuckandClaude Opus 5 e23f1f45d3 feat(starlark,on-demand): the third-party fixes worth taking, plus a Home Assistant MQTT bridge (#538)
* feat(starlark,on-demand): the third-party fixes worth taking, plus an MQTT bridge

Analysis of ant456/ledmatrix-fixes-repo, a third-party collection of
patches and services built while running this project on Starlark apps
under MQTT control. Its patches are whole-file copies taken against an
older tree, so applying them as written would revert #523's frame
pacing, #534's display() bool returns and the GitHub token masking in
plugins_manager.js. Three of its claimed fixes are already in main, and
its api_v3 Starlark routes are #535's. What follows is the rest --
verified against current code, and reimplemented where the patch's
approach did not hold up.

**On-demand display.** `pinned` reached the controller from the API, was
stored on it and republished in the status payload, but never narrowed
the rotation -- a pinned request still cycled every mode its plugin
owns. Right for a sports plugin, whose modes are views of one subject;
wrong for a plugin whose modes are unrelated, which is every Starlark
app. Now honoured, and it survives a restart.

Restarting while on-demand was active loaded *only* the on-demand
plugin, so normal rotation had nothing to return to for the life of the
process -- and a restart mid-session is routine, since that is how an
update is applied. The panel came back cycling one plugin's modes with
no way out but clearing the cache by hand. Every enabled plugin loads
now; on-demand still resumes on its saved mode.

Stop requests are exempt from the duplicate guards on purpose, so that a
second click stops a mode a race left running -- which means consuming
the mailbox is the only thing that ends one. It was never consumed, so
the same stop was re-read and re-processed on every poll, forever. Both
paths now share one compare-before-delete helper.

**Starlark rendering.** `extract_schema` parsed the source with a regex,
which can only see option lists written out literally: an app whose
dropdown is filled from a live API call inside `get_schema()` came back
empty, and the config form offered nothing to pick. Now runs `pixlet
schema`, which executes the app, and falls back to the parser when
Pixlet is absent, too old for the subcommand, or the app fails to run.
The third-party patch replaced the parser outright and hardcoded
/usr/local/bin/pixlet; this keeps the fallback and the binary search.

A `|` in a config value was dropped by a shell-metacharacter filter,
though the command is a list with no shell involved -- and apps do use
it as a separator inside one value. The key went missing silently and
the app rendered its own "not configured" screen with nothing to say
why. And a 0-byte render was reported as success: Pixlet exits 0 and
writes nothing when an app has no content, which read downstream as a
working app drawing a black panel.

**Starlark display.** `display()` ignored the mode it was called with,
so a specific app could not be addressed. It now accepts `display_mode`
-- which is the whole mechanism, since the controller inspects the
signature before passing it. Found while there: `_select_next_app` ran
only while `current_app` was unset, so with several apps installed the
first was picked once and shown forever while the rest were rendered on
schedule and never displayed. And `enable_scrolling` was missing, so
multi-frame apps were called once per rotation slot and never advanced
past frame one.

**GET /api/v3/display/modes.** Every mode that can be requested
on-demand, with the plugin that owns it. Nothing exposed this, so
anything driving the display from outside the web UI read each plugin's
manifest.json off disk and reimplemented PluginManager's fallbacks. It
also triggers discovery, which is otherwise lazy and normally happens
because a person opened the dashboard.

**integrations/mqtt_bridge.** Home Assistant control over MQTT
Discovery: a mode select, a stop button, power, brightness. Rewritten
against the API rather than the filesystem, so it needs no read access
to config.json and cannot drift from the web UI. paho-mqtt 2.x
VERSION2, TLS, an availability topic that is also the last will, and
secrets from the environment.

**Two opt-in extras.** A DNS single-request unit, for glibc's parallel
A/AAAA lookup stalling ~5s per name on routers that answer only the A
query -- which makes any plugin calling an external API slow and
Starlark apps, which have a render timeout, fail outright. And a Pixlet
config editor: a script you run and Ctrl+C rather than the third-party
version's always-on unauthenticated Flask service, since it stops the
display for the length of a session. Neither is installed by default.

Long Starlark app names now wrap instead of overflowing their card.

115 new tests across 5 files. Also unblocked
test_starlark_display_contract.py, which was silently skipping wherever
fcntl is absent. Whole suite: no new failures against main.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(mqtt_bridge): the five issues Codacy flagged on this branch

All in the new bridge, all real:

  * requests floor was 2.31.0, which carries CVE-2024-35195,
    CVE-2024-47081 and CVE-2026-25645. Raised to >=2.33.0,<3.0.0, which
    is what the project's own requirements.txt already pins.
  * `import time` was never used.
  * `"mqtt_password": None` in DEFAULTS read as a hardcoded credential.
    It is the "no password configured" default; marked nosec B105, the
    convention used elsewhere in the repo.

Also dropped an unused `build_app` from the display-modes test imports.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix: the review findings on this PR

Nine of CodeRabbit's ten, plus the CodeQL alert. The tenth is wrong and
is answered below.

**One bad config section blanked the whole mode list.**
`/display/modes` read `full_config.get(plugin_id, {}).get('enabled')`,
so a non-dict under a plugin id -- a shape DisplayController already
guards, so it happens -- raised AttributeError mid-loop and answered 500
with no modes at all. Every MQTT bridge entity is built from that list.
Now skipped with a warning.

**The DNS scripts reported success they had not earned.** Three separate
paths: `resolvconf -u` failing was swallowed by `|| true`; the
systemd-resolved branch exited 0 without applying anything, so the
oneshot unit recorded success while the workaround was inactive; and the
installer's `|| echo` turned a failed start into "installation
complete." with exit 0. All three now fail loudly. `single-request` is a
glibc resolv.conf option with no resolved.conf equivalent, so on those
hosts the honest answer is that it cannot be applied.

A NetworkManager-generated resolv.conf is regenerated on connection
changes, not only at boot, and the unit is oneshot with RemainAfterExit
-- so the option can vanish mid-boot with nothing to put it back. Now
detected and stated plainly rather than implied to be permanent.

**`Before=` does not order a manual restart.** It only orders units
already in the same transaction, so `systemctl restart ledmatrix` could
bypass the fix. install_dns_fix.sh now writes a ledmatrix.service
drop-in with Wants= and After=. Wants=, not Requires=: a DNS workaround
failing should not stop the display.

**The Pixlet editor's `--lan` is gone.** `pixlet serve` has no
authentication, and a printed warning is not access control. Loopback
only, with the SSH port-forward in the header where the flag used to be
documented -- SSH does the authenticating and nothing is left listening.

**The MQTT example config now defaults to TLS** on 8883. The installer
copies it verbatim, and without TLS the broker password and every
command cross the network in cleartext. A plaintext broker is still
supported and documented, and the bridge warns once at startup when a
password is configured without TLS.

**Not taken: "the upstream Pixlet CLI has no `schema` subcommand."**
Upstream tidbyt/pixlet has none, but `scripts/download_pixlet.sh`
installs `tronbyt/pixlet`, whose `cmd/schema.go` is
`schema [PATH]` -> JSON on stdout, built on
`runtime.NewAppletFromPath`, so it does execute `get_schema()`. That is
exactly what extract_schema_via_pixlet calls. A binary without the
subcommand exits non-zero and falls back to the source parser, which is
already covered by a test.

**CodeQL stack-trace exposure: not taken either.** I removed `details`
first and that broke
test_web_error_detail.py::test_no_api_v3_handler_discards_its_exception,
which enforces `describe_exception` across all ~75 handlers -- written
because a device with failing storage answered "see logs for details"
from the log viewer itself. describe_exception redacts credentials; the
trade-off is the project's and is already made. Restored, with the
reasoning in a comment.

11 new tests. Whole suite: no new failures against main, 4127 passed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-08 08:34:52 -04:00

211 lines
8.7 KiB
Python

"""starlark-apps PixletRenderer: what reaches Pixlet, and what counts as a render.
Three things a Starlark app can do that the renderer got wrong:
* put a "|" in a config value -- a shell metacharacter filter dropped the
whole key, though the command is a list and no shell is involved;
* render nothing -- Pixlet exits 0 and writes a 0-byte file, which was
reported as a successful render;
* compute its schema at runtime -- the source parser can only read option
lists that are written out literally, so a dropdown fed by a live API call
came back empty.
"""
import importlib.util
import json
import subprocess
import sys
from pathlib import Path
from unittest.mock import patch
import pytest
PLUGIN_DIR = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "plugin-repos" / "starlark-apps"
@pytest.fixture(scope="module")
def renderer_module():
if not PLUGIN_DIR.exists():
pytest.skip("starlark-apps plugin is not checked out")
sys.path.insert(0, str(PLUGIN_DIR))
try:
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(
"pixlet_renderer_under_test", PLUGIN_DIR / "pixlet_renderer.py")
module = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
spec.loader.exec_module(module)
return module
except Exception as e: # noqa: BLE001 - optional deps may be absent
pytest.skip(f"pixlet_renderer is not importable here: {e}")
finally:
sys.path.remove(str(PLUGIN_DIR))
@pytest.fixture
def renderer(renderer_module):
"""A renderer with a known binary and __init__'s binary search bypassed."""
r = renderer_module.PixletRenderer.__new__(renderer_module.PixletRenderer)
r.timeout = 30
r.pixlet_binary = "/usr/local/bin/pixlet"
return r
def _completed(returncode=0, stdout="", stderr=""):
return subprocess.CompletedProcess(args=[], returncode=returncode,
stdout=stdout, stderr=stderr)
class TestConfigValuesReachPixlet:
"""cmd is a list and there is no shell=True, so nothing here is ever
interpreted by a shell -- the filter is defence in depth, not a boundary."""
def _args_for(self, renderer, tmp_path, config):
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("# app", encoding="utf-8")
out = tmp_path / "out.webp"
def fake_run(cmd, **kw):
out.write_bytes(b"webp-bytes")
fake_run.cmd = cmd
return _completed()
with patch.object(subprocess, "run", side_effect=fake_run):
renderer.render(str(tmp_path / "app.star"), str(out), config=config)
return fake_run.cmd
def test_a_pipe_in_a_value_is_passed_through(self, renderer, tmp_path):
"""Real apps use "|" as a separator inside one config value."""
args = self._args_for(renderer, tmp_path, {"sign_id": "I-476 North|175659"})
assert "sign_id=I-476 North|175659" in args
def test_a_dropped_value_does_not_take_the_key_with_it(self, renderer, tmp_path):
args = self._args_for(renderer, tmp_path, {"sign_id": "I-476 North|175659"})
assert any(a.startswith("sign_id=") for a in args)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("value", [
"$(rm -rf /)",
"`whoami`",
"a;b",
"a&b",
"a>b",
"a<b",
])
def test_actual_shell_metacharacters_are_still_dropped(self, renderer, tmp_path, value):
args = self._args_for(renderer, tmp_path, {"k": value})
assert not any(a.startswith("k=") for a in args)
def test_an_invalid_key_is_still_dropped(self, renderer, tmp_path):
args = self._args_for(renderer, tmp_path, {"bad key!": "x"})
assert not any("bad key!" in a for a in args)
class TestAnEmptyRenderIsNotASuccess:
"""Pixlet exits 0 and writes 0 bytes when an app renders no content."""
def _render(self, renderer, tmp_path, write_bytes):
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("# app", encoding="utf-8")
out = tmp_path / "out.webp"
def fake_run(cmd, **kw):
out.write_bytes(write_bytes)
return _completed()
with patch.object(subprocess, "run", side_effect=fake_run):
return renderer.render(str(tmp_path / "app.star"), str(out))
def test_a_zero_byte_output_is_reported_as_a_failure(self, renderer, tmp_path):
ok, error = self._render(renderer, tmp_path, b"")
assert ok is False
assert "empty" in (error or "").lower()
def test_a_real_output_still_succeeds(self, renderer, tmp_path):
ok, error = self._render(renderer, tmp_path, b"RIFF....WEBP")
assert (ok, error) == (True, None)
def test_a_missing_output_still_fails(self, renderer, tmp_path):
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("# app", encoding="utf-8")
out = tmp_path / "out.webp"
with patch.object(subprocess, "run", return_value=_completed()):
ok, error = renderer.render(str(tmp_path / "app.star"), str(out))
assert ok is False
assert "not found" in (error or "").lower()
class TestSchemaComesFromPixletWhenItCan:
"""`pixlet schema` runs get_schema(); the source parser only reads it.
An app whose dropdown options come from a live API call has no option list
anywhere in its source, so the parser reports an empty dropdown and the
config form offers nothing to choose.
"""
PIXLET_OUTPUT = json.dumps({
"version": "1",
"schema": [
{"id": "roadway", "name": "Roadway", "type": "dropdown",
"description": "Pick a road", "options": [{"display": "I-476", "value": "476"}]},
],
})
def test_the_pixlet_output_is_used(self, renderer, tmp_path):
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("# no schema literal anywhere\n", encoding="utf-8")
with patch.object(subprocess, "run",
return_value=_completed(stdout=self.PIXLET_OUTPUT)):
ok, schema, error = renderer.extract_schema(str(star))
assert ok is True and error is None
assert schema["schema"][0]["options"][0]["value"] == "476"
def test_pixlet_field_keys_are_remapped_for_the_config_form(self, renderer, tmp_path):
"""The UI reads typeOf/desc; Pixlet emits type/description."""
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("#\n", encoding="utf-8")
with patch.object(subprocess, "run",
return_value=_completed(stdout=self.PIXLET_OUTPUT)):
_, schema, _ = renderer.extract_schema(str(star))
field = schema["schema"][0]
assert field["typeOf"] == "dropdown"
assert field["desc"] == "Pick a road"
assert "type" not in field and "description" not in field
@pytest.mark.parametrize("outcome", [
{"return_value": _completed(returncode=1, stderr="unknown command \"schema\"")},
{"return_value": _completed(stdout="not json at all")},
{"side_effect": subprocess.TimeoutExpired(cmd="pixlet", timeout=20)},
{"side_effect": OSError("no such binary")},
])
def test_it_falls_back_to_the_source_parser(self, renderer, tmp_path, outcome):
"""Older Pixlet has no `schema` subcommand, and an app can fail to run.
Neither should cost the schema an app does state literally."""
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text(
'def get_schema():\n'
' return schema.Schema(version = "1", fields = [\n'
' schema.Text(id = "city", name = "City", desc = "Your city",'
' icon = "gear"),\n'
' ])\n',
encoding="utf-8")
with patch.object(subprocess, "run", **outcome):
ok, parsed, error = renderer.extract_schema(str(star))
assert ok is True and error is None
assert [f["id"] for f in parsed["schema"]] == ["city"]
def test_no_pixlet_binary_skips_straight_to_the_parser(self, renderer, tmp_path):
renderer.pixlet_binary = None
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("#\n", encoding="utf-8")
assert renderer.extract_schema_via_pixlet(str(star)) is None
def test_a_missing_star_file_is_still_an_error(self, renderer, tmp_path):
ok, schema, error = renderer.extract_schema(str(tmp_path / "gone.star"))
assert ok is False and schema is None and "not found" in error
def test_an_unexpected_pixlet_shape_is_not_trusted(self, renderer, tmp_path):
"""A bare list, or a dict with no schema array, must not reach the UI."""
star = tmp_path / "app.star"
star.write_text("#\n", encoding="utf-8")
with patch.object(subprocess, "run",
return_value=_completed(stdout='["not", "a", "schema"]')):
assert renderer.extract_schema_via_pixlet(str(star)) is None