refactor(web): use canonical secret helpers in api_v3; make ConfigManager secret strip/merge array-aware

api_v3.py carried three inline nested copies of find_secret_fields/
separate_secrets (main-config save, plugin-config save, plugin-config
reset). They drifted from each other (one lacked isinstance guards) and
none supported the canonical module's array-item secrets
(accounts[].token). All three endpoints now import from
src/web_interface/secret_helpers.

Adopting the canonical behavior makes array-item secrets reachable, and
their parallel-placeholder shape ([{'token': ...}, {}] alongside the
regular list) was not survivable by ConfigManager's round-trip:
_strip_secrets_recursive dropped the whole key (losing the regular
fields from config.json) and _deep_merge replaced the regular list
wholesale on load. Both are now array-aware:

- strip removes the secret fields from each item and ALWAYS keeps the
  list so indices survive for merge-on-load; whole-key secrets (scalar
  lists, shape mismatches) still drop the key entirely — never leak.
- merge folds each secrets item into the config item at the same index,
  skipping {} placeholders. The regular list's length is authoritative
  in both directions: a user deleting an array item never has it
  resurrected from a stale secrets entry (extras warn and are ignored).

api_v3's own deep_merge intentionally still replaces lists wholesale —
form posts carry complete arrays and index-merging would resurrect
deleted items; a comment now documents that.

Tests: the parity guard flips from 'exactly 3 inline copies' to 'zero,
and the canonical import must exist'; TestArraySecretStripAndMerge
covers the new strip/merge semantics incl. length-mismatch contracts;
new test_api_v3_secret_roundtrip.py drives all three endpoints through
a Flask client with a REAL ConfigManager+SchemaManager over tmp_path,
proving secrets land in config_secrets.json, config.json stays clean,
and a fresh load merges them back into the right array items.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NohXi78cwsAKtN1sCfxjUh
This commit is contained in:
Claude
2026-08-07 17:33:47 +00:00
parent 003312f4ff
commit 2efd49a1ab
5 changed files with 478 additions and 173 deletions
@@ -1,18 +1,13 @@
"""
Drift guard for the duplicated secret-separation logic.
Drift guard: api_v3 must use the canonical secret helpers.
src/web_interface/secret_helpers.py is the canonical implementation of
find_secret_fields / separate_secrets, but web_interface/blueprints/api_v3.py
still carries THREE inline nested-function copies of each (in the plugin
config GET, POST, and reset endpoints). The copies lack the canonical
module's array-item support (`accounts[].token`), so migrating an endpoint
onto the module is a behavior change that must be made deliberately.
This file guards two things:
1. The copy count can only go DOWN. A fourth copy appearing means someone
re-implemented the logic again instead of importing secret_helpers.
2. The known behavioral gap is documented as an executable fact, so whoever
migrates the endpoints knows exactly what changes.
Historically web_interface/blueprints/api_v3.py carried THREE inline
nested-function copies of ``find_secret_fields``/``separate_secrets`` (in the
main-config save, plugin-config save, and plugin-config reset endpoints).
They lacked the canonical module's array-item secret support and drifted from
each other. They have been migrated onto
``src/web_interface/secret_helpers`` — this file now guards against copies
REAPPEARING, and keeps the canonical array-item behavior executable.
"""
import re
@@ -23,77 +18,44 @@ from src.web_interface.secret_helpers import find_secret_fields, separate_secret
API_V3_PATH = (Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2]
/ "web_interface" / "blueprints" / "api_v3.py")
# Update DOWNWARD as endpoints migrate onto src/web_interface/secret_helpers.
EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES = 3
# The migration is complete: any inline reimplementation is a regression.
EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES = 0
class TestInlineCopyCount:
class TestNoInlineCopies:
def _count(self, name: str) -> int:
source = API_V3_PATH.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
return len(re.findall(rf"^\s*def {name}\(", source, flags=re.MULTILINE))
def test_find_secret_fields_copy_count(self):
def test_no_inline_find_secret_fields(self):
count = self._count("find_secret_fields")
assert count == EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES, (
f"api_v3.py has {count} inline find_secret_fields definitions, "
f"expected {EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES}. New code must import it from "
f"src/web_interface/secret_helpers instead of re-implementing it; "
f"if you migrated an endpoint, lower EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES."
f"expected {EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES}. Import it from "
f"src/web_interface/secret_helpers instead of re-implementing it."
)
def test_separate_secrets_copy_count(self):
def test_no_inline_separate_secrets(self):
count = self._count("separate_secrets")
assert count == EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES, (
f"api_v3.py has {count} inline separate_secrets definitions, "
f"expected {EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES}. New code must import it from "
f"src/web_interface/secret_helpers instead of re-implementing it; "
f"if you migrated an endpoint, lower EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES."
f"expected {EXPECTED_INLINE_COPIES}. Import it from "
f"src/web_interface/secret_helpers instead of re-implementing it."
)
def test_inline_copies_lack_array_item_support(self):
"""The documented gap: no inline copy recurses into array `items`
schemas, so array-item secrets (accounts[].token) are NOT routed to
config_secrets.json by these endpoints. The canonical module handles
them. When an endpoint migrates onto the module that behavior
changes (a fix, but a deliberate one).
If this fails, an inline copy has grown array support — duplicating
the canonical module even harder. Migrate the endpoint onto
src/web_interface/secret_helpers instead.
"""
for body in self._inline_bodies("find_secret_fields"):
# Array handling requires checking type == 'array'; no inline
# copy does. (Can't grep bare "items" — properties.items() the
# dict method appears legitimately.)
assert "'array'" not in body and '"array"' not in body
@staticmethod
def _inline_bodies(name: str):
"""Extract each inline def's body from api_v3.py by indentation."""
lines = API_V3_PATH.read_text(encoding="utf-8").splitlines()
bodies = []
i = 0
while i < len(lines):
match = re.match(rf"^(\s+)def {name}\(", lines[i])
if not match:
i += 1
continue
indent = len(match.group(1))
body = [lines[i]]
i += 1
while i < len(lines):
line = lines[i]
if line.strip() and (len(line) - len(line.lstrip())) <= indent:
break
body.append(line)
i += 1
bodies.append("\n".join(body))
assert bodies, f"no inline {name} definitions found"
return bodies
def test_canonical_import_present(self):
# Tripwire: the endpoints still need the helpers, so removing the
# import means either dead secret handling or a new local copy.
source = API_V3_PATH.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
assert re.search(
r"from src\.web_interface\.secret_helpers import .*find_secret_fields",
source,
), "api_v3.py no longer imports the canonical secret helpers"
class TestCanonicalArrayItemBehavior:
"""Executable documentation of what migrating endpoints will change."""
"""Executable documentation of the array-item secret contract the
endpoints now inherit from the canonical module."""
SCHEMA = {
"accounts": {